
You can bring a horse to water but you can’t make it drink
Here’s one for you. She fell, and then she fell again. She has fallen so many times that it would be more efficient to list the times when she didn’t. But she doesn’t need help. She’s not, as she has said, “an idiot.” Wait a minute. Now I am not a judgmental person, but I will play the role of devil’s advocate, yes, aunt of a client whose name shall remain safe with me, YOU are an idiot.
Why? Because you have at your disposal many nieces and nephews ready willing and able to help you find the care that you need, and you can afford it, but you are not one of those old people. Yet, you lay on your floor for 7 hours with a towel over your head until someone, I mean some people—plural, picked your 300 pound body off of the floor. You have cracked your head open twice from falling and you are bound to break your hip and die. That’s what often happens to 76 year old women who break their hips.
I know that this sounds a bit ungerontologist like, but I adopt this demeanor to make a point, as ineloquent as it might sound….You can take a horse to water, but you cannot make it drink. She may be an idiot, but she is not delusional. Or is she?
Where is that line? It is the same question I have when I ponder the criminal defense not guilty by reason of insanity. Isn’t everyone who kills another person insane? Isn’t every person who chooses to live life on their terms when those terms mean self neglect insane? O.K., maybe it is a bad analogy, but we as a society and our legal system are going to have to seriously start thinking about this right to self determination.
Is it her right to break her hip and die on her floor? Is it the right of a person suffering from Alzheimer’s to be euthanized if that is a wish communicated when that person was as lucid as Albert Einstein, who as I might remind you, was the genius among geniuses who discovered, merely by thinking about it, that the universe was not as it seemed?
Is it the right of an older adult to slam the door on me when I come to see how they are doing upon being hired by an adult child? Is it my right to call those people idiots (even though it was in my non-judgmental role as devil’s advocate)?
I say, yes, yes and yes again. I believe in the right to self determination, period. HOW ABOUT YOU?















